Experimenting with the shutter speed is the best way to determine the correct shutter/aperture combination for your situation. In this case, the version doesn't imply enough motion to be effective; the & versions are better.
Trick, Photography Book - Fractures Awesome Infographic of Photography Mistakes to Avoid! (Plus 58 more tips on the site!) - Now YOU Can Create Mind-Blowing Artistic Images With Top Secret Photography Tutorials With Step-By-Step Instructions!